The Indifferent Stars Above

The Indifferent Stars Above Plot Summary

Introduction

# Dreams to Disaster: The Donner Party's Fatal Journey West In the spring of 1846, twenty-one-year-old Sarah Graves stood at a crossroads that would define not only her own fate but also illuminate one of the most harrowing chapters in American westward expansion. Newly married to Jay Fosdick, she faced an agonizing choice: remain in Illinois with her husband or join her family's journey to California's promised land. Her decision to convince Jay to accompany her family west would thrust them into an ordeal that tested the very limits of human endurance and moral boundaries. The story of the Donner Party reveals profound truths about the American pioneer experience that extend far beyond the sensational headlines of survival and cannibalism. It exposes the dangerous gap between promotional promises and harsh realities, showing how ordinary families pursuing the American dream could be led astray by false information and poor timing. More fundamentally, it demonstrates how quickly the veneer of civilization can erode when humans face starvation and death, yet also reveals extraordinary examples of courage, sacrifice, and the will to survive against impossible odds.

Chapter 1: Westward Dreams: The Decision to Leave for California in 1846

The great westward migration of 1846 was born from a perfect storm of economic desperation and boundless optimism. Across the Midwest, families like the Graves had endured nearly a decade of economic depression following the Panic of 1837. Franklin Ward Graves watched helplessly as wheat prices plummeted to half the cost of production, while recurring bouts of malaria—the dreaded "Illinois shakes"—reminded settlers of their vulnerability in the swampy Mississippi River valley. For thousands of American families, California represented not just opportunity but salvation itself. The dream was fueled by persuasive literature, particularly Lansford Hastings' "The Emigrants' Guide to Oregon and California," published in 1845. Hastings painted California as an earthly paradise, describing "the extraordinary variety and abundance of its productions" and promising a climate so perfect that crops grew year-round. These glowing accounts circulated through newspapers and word of mouth, creating what historian David McCullough might have called a "fever of expectation" that swept across farming communities from Illinois to Missouri. When Franklin Graves sold his 500-acre farm for $1,500 in silver coins—cleverly hidden beneath wooden cleats in his wagon—he was making more than a financial transaction. He was betting everything on the fundamental American belief in manifest destiny and the possibility of reinvention on the frontier. The Graves family's departure on April 12, 1846, with three farm wagons loaded with hopes and possessions, embodied the pioneer spirit that would define a generation. Yet even as they crossed the Missouri River at St. Joseph, entering territory where no stores or reliable supply points existed, an ominous warning went unheeded. Hastings himself had advised that emigrants "must never start" after May 1st if it could possibly be avoided. When the Graves family crossed into the wilderness, May Day was already three weeks past—a delay that would prove more consequential than anyone could have imagined.

Chapter 2: Fatal Shortcut: Hastings Cutoff Deception and Mounting Delays

By July 1846, the westward journey had settled into a rhythm of daily challenges and steady progress. The Graves family had successfully navigated swollen rivers, violent thunderstorms, and encounters with Native Americans, including a spectacular gathering of two thousand Sioux warriors at Fort Laramie. Their spirits remained high as they celebrated the Fourth of July with patriotic fervor, still believing they were on schedule to reach California before winter. The crucial moment came at the "Parting of the Ways" on the Little Sandy River, where emigrants faced a choice between the established northern route to Fort Hall and a southwestern branch toward Fort Bridger. At Fort Bridger, Jim Bridger and Louis Vasquez enthusiastically promoted Hastings' cutoff, describing it as "a fine level road, with plenty of water and grass" that would save 350-400 miles. What they concealed were letters from previous travelers warning against the route. The fort's proprietors had a vested financial interest in promoting any path that would bring more business their way. When the Graves family caught up with the Donner Party on August 10 at Weber Canyon, they discovered the terrible reality behind Hastings' promises. The "shortcut" had become a nightmare of dense thickets and boulder-strewn passages. For six grueling days, teams of men attacked each oak tree with axes, hacking through brush so thick and tough that progress was measured in yards rather than miles. The thirty-five-mile passage through the Wasatch Mountains consumed sixteen days—more than twice the promised time. The delays compounded as they crossed the Great Salt Lake Desert. Hastings had described a forty-mile, two-day crossing, but the reality was nearly eighty miles of waterless salt flats under a merciless sun. Oxen collapsed from exhaustion and thirst, forcing families to abandon precious wagons and supplies. By September 10, snow was already visible on distant peaks—nature's warning that winter approached with indifferent inevitability. The party's unity further fractured when James Reed fatally stabbed teamster John Snyder during a heated argument, resulting in Reed's banishment just when leadership and cooperation were most essential for survival.

Chapter 3: Winter's Trap: Snowbound in the Sierra Nevada Mountains

October 31, 1846, marked the beginning of the Donner Party's descent into nightmare. After months of delays, they finally reached the eastern base of the Sierra Nevada, tantalizingly close to California's safety. Their first attempt to cross the pass near Donner Lake encountered several inches of snow, but they pressed forward with desperate determination. As they climbed toward the summit, however, the snow deepened to three or four feet, making progress impossible for their exhausted oxen. The next day brought another attempt and another failure. On November 2, as they struggled upward through even deeper snow, a new storm began with deceptive gentleness—soft, feathery flakes that would seal their fate. By morning, they awoke buried in fresh snow, facing the terrible realization that they were trapped for the winter with dwindling supplies and wholly inadequate shelter. The party hastily constructed three crude cabins near the lake, while the Donner families, caught several miles behind at Alder Creek, could manage only brush shelters covered with hides and canvas. For eight consecutive days, snow fell continuously, burying their makeshift homes. When Franklin Graves led a desperate escape attempt on November 12 with Sarah and others, they were quickly defeated by snow so deep they sank to their thighs with each step. By late November, another storm had buried the cabins under six to seven feet of snow. Patrick Breen, who kept a diary throughout the ordeal, captured their desperation: "Difficult to get wood no going from the house completely housed up... no hopes of finding them alive." The emigrants cut steps into the snow to climb from their doorways to the surface, creating a surreal world where they lived like moles beneath twenty feet of white. Inside the cabins, conditions deteriorated with each passing day. Virtually no light penetrated except for flickering fires whose smoke stung their eyes relentlessly. The cold was bone-deep and constant, causing hands and feet to ache around the clock. The cabins reeked of wet wool, unwashed bodies, and human waste. Outside, the indifferent stars looked down on a prison of white from which there seemed no escape, no mercy, and no hope.

Chapter 4: Desperate Survival: Starvation and the Resort to Cannibalism

By mid-December 1846, the specter of starvation haunted every conversation and consumed every thought. The emigrants had slaughtered their remaining cattle, but the stringy meat was nearly gone. Game had vanished to lower elevations, and their attempts at fishing through the lake's ice yielded nothing. They boiled oxhide into a glutinous mass, gnawed on bones until they splintered, and searched desperately for anything remotely edible. The physical effects of prolonged starvation followed a predictable but devastating pattern. Bodies began consuming themselves from within—first glycogen stores, then fat reserves, finally muscle tissue. Metabolisms slowed dramatically, making them hypersensitive to cold even as their body temperatures dropped. Hearts literally shrank, blood pressure fell, and lung capacity diminished. The psychological changes were equally disturbing as hunger became an obsession that dominated every waking moment. On December 16, seventeen of the strongest members formed the "Forlorn Hope"—a desperate attempt to cross the mountains on improvised snowshoes and bring back rescue. Sarah Graves Fosdick and her husband Jay were among this group, carrying only six days' worth of meager rations for what they believed would be a week-long journey. The reality proved far more brutal: struggling through snow sometimes ten feet deep, they became disoriented in the vast whiteness, their homemade snowshoes causing painful blisters and cuts. On Christmas Day, having been without food for four days, the snowshoe party faced the ultimate taboo. Patrick Dolan died that night from starvation and exposure, and the next morning, the survivors cut flesh from his body and roasted it over their fire. Sarah initially declared she would "die before she would eat of the body," but was eventually "prevailed upon to taste a little." When Jay Fosdick died on January 8, Sarah faced the unbearable reality of leaving his body behind as the others continued their desperate quest for help. After thirty-three days of unimaginable suffering, seven survivors of the snowshoe party—including Sarah—staggered into a Native American village in the foothills. They had traveled roughly eighty miles through some of North America's most challenging terrain in the dead of winter, sustained only by their will to live and the flesh of their dead companions.

Chapter 5: Race Against Death: The Snowshoe Party's Perilous Rescue Mission

The arrival of the snowshoe party survivors in the Sacramento Valley on January 17, 1847, galvanized California's small population into immediate action. James Reed, who had been banished from the party months earlier, had already attempted one rescue mission in November, only to be turned back by impassable snow. Now, with firsthand accounts of the horror unfolding in the mountains, the urgency became overwhelming. The first relief party, led by Aquilla Glover and Reason Tucker, departed on February 4 with seven men and limited supplies. Their journey into the mountains was itself an epic of endurance—battling through snow sometimes twenty feet deep, camping in temperatures well below freezing, and navigating treacherous terrain without proper maps. After seven grueling days, they reached the lake camps on February 18 to find scenes that defied description. The rescuers discovered survivors who had been reduced to living skeletons, their eyes sunken and their bodies wasted by months of starvation. The cabins were half-buried in snow, accessible only through tunnels, and the stench of death and human waste was overwhelming. Patrick Breen's diary entry captured the moment: "Relief, thank God, relief has come at last." Yet the rescuers faced agonizing decisions about whom to save first, as they could carry only limited supplies and escort only the strongest survivors. Twenty-three people, mostly children, left with the first relief party, but the journey back proved nearly as perilous as the rescue itself. The second relief party, led by James Reed, arrived on March 1 to find his own family barely alive. Reed's wife Margret was so emaciated he barely recognized her, and his children were clinging to life by the thinnest of threads. This party evacuated seventeen more survivors, but was caught in a blizzard that created what became known as "Starved Camp," where more lives were lost. The third and fourth relief parties found fewer and fewer survivors, with evidence that cannibalism had become routine among those still alive. By April, when the final rescue party reached the camps, they found only Louis Keseberg alive at the lake, surrounded by the gruesome remains of those who had not survived the winter. The rescue missions represented extraordinary courage and determination, with men risking their own lives to save strangers trapped in what one rescuer called "a perfect hell on earth."

Chapter 6: Relief and Recovery: Rescue Efforts and Return to Civilization

The rescue of the Donner Party required four separate relief expeditions between February and April 1847, each facing its own perils and tragedies. Of the 87 people who had entered the mountains, only 48 survived—a mortality rate that fell disproportionately on adult males, who died at nearly twice the rate of women and children. This pattern reflected both the greater physical demands placed on men and women's superior adaptation to extreme cold and starvation. When survivors finally reached California settlements, they faced challenges that extended far beyond physical recovery. Many suffered what we would now recognize as severe post-traumatic stress disorder. Mary Ann Graves, Sarah's sister, later confided, "I wish I could cry but I cannot. If I could forget the tragedy, perhaps I would know how to cry again." The children, in particular, carried psychological scars that would affect them for the rest of their lives. The public reaction to the Donner Party's ordeal was complex and often contradictory. Initial newspaper reports in California were sympathetic, focusing on the heroic rescue efforts and the survivors' courage. However, as details of cannibalism spread to eastern newspapers, sensationalized accounts began to appear. Some survivors, particularly Louis Keseberg, were vilified and accused of murder, while others like Tamzene Donner, who chose to stay with her dying husband rather than save herself, were celebrated as martyrs. Despite their trauma, many survivors demonstrated remarkable resilience in rebuilding their lives. Sarah Graves Fosdick remarried within months of her rescue, perhaps seeking security after losing so much. James Reed prospered in San Jose, becoming a prominent businessman and civic leader. The orphaned Donner children were adopted by California families and grew up to become respected members of their communities, though they carried their secrets quietly throughout their lives. The immediate practical impact of the Donner Party tragedy was significant. Emigrant guidebooks became more accurate and honest about the dangers of untested routes. Warning stations were established in the Sierra Nevada, and the route itself was improved with better marked trails. Most importantly, the disaster served as a cautionary tale that influenced thousands of subsequent emigrants to avoid shortcuts and maintain realistic schedules for their westward journeys.

Chapter 7: Legacy of Endurance: Survivors' Stories and Historical Impact

The Donner Party tragedy transcended its immediate historical moment to become one of the most enduring and complex stories in American folklore. Unlike many frontier tales that celebrate triumph over adversity, the Donner story forces us to confront uncomfortable questions about human nature, moral boundaries, and the price of survival. It reveals how quickly the veneer of civilization can erode when people face starvation and death, yet also demonstrates extraordinary examples of courage and self-sacrifice. The survivors themselves responded differently to their newfound notoriety. Some, like Virginia Reed, spoke and wrote openly about their experiences, contributing to historical accounts that helped preserve the truth of what happened. Others, like many of the Donner children, maintained silence about their ordeal, carrying their trauma privately throughout their lives. Nancy Graves would burst into tears without warning for years afterward, mystifying schoolmates who didn't understand her "particular, individual secret." The story's impact on American culture has been profound and lasting. It became a cautionary tale about the dangers of overconfidence and the pursuit of shortcuts, but also a testament to human endurance and the will to survive. The focus on cannibalism in popular retellings has sometimes overshadowed the more complex human drama of leadership, community bonds, and moral choices under extreme pressure. Modern historians have worked to present a more nuanced understanding that honors both the suffering and the courage of those involved. For the descendants of survivors, the legacy remains deeply personal. Many have worked tirelessly to preserve accurate historical accounts and combat sensationalized versions of their ancestors' experiences. Archaeological work at the Donner Party sites has provided physical evidence that confirms or corrects historical accounts, helping to separate fact from folklore. The Donner Memorial State Park now stands as a testament to both the tragedy and the resilience of those who endured it. Perhaps most significantly, the Donner Party story continues to resonate because it addresses timeless questions about human nature and survival. In our modern world of technological convenience, it reminds us of our fundamental vulnerability to natural forces and our dependence on preparation, good judgment, and community support. Their experience serves as both a sobering reminder of nature's indifference to human suffering and an inspiring example of the human capacity to endure seemingly impossible circumstances.

Summary

The Donner Party tragedy represents a convergence of human error, environmental extremes, and cruel timing that transformed an ordinary emigrant journey into one of history's most harrowing survival stories. At its heart, the disaster stemmed from a cascade of poor decisions—most notably the choice to follow Lansford Hastings' untested shortcut—that cost precious weeks and placed the emigrants in the Sierra Nevada just as winter arrived. The subsequent months of entrapment revealed both the fragility of human civilization and the extraordinary lengths people will go to survive and save others. The story's enduring significance extends far beyond its historical context to illuminate fundamental truths about human nature and community under extreme stress. It demonstrates how quickly social bonds can fray when basic needs go unmet, yet also shows remarkable examples of self-sacrifice and courage. The Donner Party's experience offers sobering lessons about the dangers of overconfidence, the importance of accurate information, and the value of community cooperation in facing life's challenges. In our contemporary world, their story serves as a powerful reminder that despite technological advances, we remain vulnerable to natural forces and dependent on preparation, sound judgment, and the willingness to help others in times of crisis.

About Author

Loading

Daniel James Brown

Brown illuminates the profound narratives of resilience and courage that reside within historical events. His work as an author delves into the lives of ordinary individuals who achieve extraordinary feats, driven by meticulous research and a dedication to preserving pivotal historical moments. Brown's exploration of these themes is exemplified in his acclaimed book, "The Boys in the Boat," which details the inspiring journey of nine young men striving for Olympic glory amidst the Great Depression. By weaving personal stories with the broader sweep of history, Brown invites readers to experience the intricate tapestry of human experience through his compelling prose.\n\nIn addition to "The Boys in the Boat," Brown's literary contributions include "Facing the Mountain," an evocative account of Japanese American heroes during World War II, and "The Indifferent Stars Above," which recounts the harrowing journey of the Donner Party. His early book, "Under a Flaming Sky," revisits the tragic Hinckley firestorm, showcasing his ability to intertwine personal narratives with national catastrophes. Through his narrative style, characterized by a vivid blend of historical accuracy and literary elegance, Brown reaches a diverse audience eager to connect with the indomitable human spirit across various historical contexts.\n\nBrown's commitment to storytelling that honors perseverance and valor has garnered widespread recognition, positioning him as a distinguished figure in historical literature. His works resonate with readers who appreciate both the scholarly depth and accessible nature of his writing. As a result, his bio stands as a testament to his enduring impact in bringing to light stories that might otherwise have remained in the shadows, thus enriching the literary landscape with invaluable insights into the human condition.

Read more