All Shook Up

All Shook Up Plot Summary

Introduction

The gas gauge read "Empty" when J.D. Carver's vintage Mustang rolled into Star Lake, Washington—it always read empty, the needle stuck since '93. His trunk held power tools, his backseat two table saws, and his pocket carried an antique gold watch that haunted him with memories of betrayal. Twenty years after fleeing from the only woman who'd ever tried to love him, he'd inherited half of Star Lake Lodge from that same woman—Edwina Lawrence. Now he faced another Lawrence: Dru, the lodge's general manager with eyes like electric blue flame and a ten-year-old son who looked at J.D. like he hung the moon. She was everything J.D. had learned not to want—decent, rooted, the kind of woman who expected love to last. But Star Lake had a way of stripping away a man's defenses, one shared glance, one tender moment at a time. And J.D. was about to discover that sometimes the thing you've spent your whole life running from is exactly what you need to survive.

Chapter 1: The Reluctant Heir: J.D.'s Unwelcome Arrival at Star Lake Lodge

J.D. squatted before the massive fieldstone fireplace, studying the cracked andiron with professional eyes. Twenty years of construction work had taught him to spot structural weakness, but nothing had prepared him for the weakness he felt when the lodge manager approached. "Mr. Carver?" Her voice carried that crisp mountain air quality—clean, no-nonsense. He turned. She stood there in her neat polo shirt and walking shorts, a clipboard tucked under one arm, looking like she'd stepped out of some tourism brochure. Brown hair caught the lobby's amber light, and when their eyes met, something electric passed between them that had nothing to do with the lodge's rustic charm. "Don't call me mister. My name's J.D." He rose to his full height, noting how she had to tip her head back to meet his gaze. "And I'm Dru Lawrence. Welcome to Star Lake Lodge." Her handshake was firm, professional. But J.D. felt the slight tremor in her fingers, the way her pulse jumped at her wrist. Good. He wasn't the only one feeling off-balance. "That andiron is nearly in two pieces," he said, nodding toward the fireplace. "It needs to be pulled out and soldered." Dru's smile never wavered, but something cooled in those blue eyes. "I'll make a note of that." The front desk manager rushed over, breathless with some crisis about water-skiers and sick employees. J.D. watched Dru handle it with practiced efficiency, her voice never losing that polite warmth even as she solved problems on the fly. She had authority here, respect. The kind of roots J.D. had never known. When she led him through the lodge's polished halls toward his cabin, he found himself studying the sway of her hips, the confident set of her shoulders. She spoke of the lodge's history—eighty-odd years in business, four generations of Lawrences running it like a well-oiled machine. "So where's Mr. Lawrence?" he asked as they walked the tree-lined path. "Uncle Ben? He's—" "Your husband, sweetheart." Her laugh held an edge. "Doesn't exist. Gone with the wind, his memory is dust." At the cabin, she showed him the missing porch roof with apologetic efficiency. J.D. barely heard her explanations. He was too busy watching the way late afternoon light caught in her hair, the way she gestured with hands that looked soft enough to— "I can live with that," he said about the roof, though he was thinking about entirely different accommodations. As she prepared to leave, her phone rang. Another crisis, another smooth solution. J.D. recognized competence when he saw it. This woman ran things, made decisions that mattered. She wasn't some small-town sweetheart waiting for a man to complete her life. Which made the heat in his gut that much more dangerous. After she left, J.D. stood on his broken porch and stared through the trees toward the lodge. Edwina had left him more than just property. She'd dropped him into the middle of a life he'd never imagined—one where people stayed, where they built things meant to last generations. The gold watch felt heavy in his pocket, a reminder of the last time he'd believed in forever.

Chapter 2: Sparks and Suspicion: Growing Attraction Between Unlikely Partners

Dru told herself the front desk assignment was purely business—J.D. needed to learn the lodge from the ground up. She didn't admit, even to herself, how often she found excuses to check on his progress. He looked ridiculous behind the polished mahogany counter in his required khakis and polo shirt, like a wolf dressed for Sunday dinner. The lodge guests loved him—or rather, the women did. He had a way of leaning against the counter that made tourist wives forget their husbands' names. But J.D. clearly hated every minute of it. "Some people give new meaning to the word 'rude,'" he told her after a particularly difficult check-in. His usual white t-shirt was back on, the uniform discarded. "And my natural inclination isn't to turn the other cheek." Dru almost smiled at the understatement. She'd seen him handle the complaints, the condescending remarks, the casual cruelty that some guests seemed to think their money entitled them to. His jaw would tick, his hands would clench, but he'd kept his voice level. "You did fine," she said. "I did lousy and we both know it. Put me back on maintenance crew. I'm not built for customer service." But when elderly Mrs. Manion arrived with her downtrodden daughter, J.D. surprised everyone. The old woman terrorized their young bellhop Sean with sharp words and impossible demands until J.D. stepped in. "If you find so much disfavor with Sean's work, Mrs. Manion," his voice cut through the lobby like tempered steel, "perhaps you ought to do it yourself." The confrontation escalated until Mrs. Manion threatened to have him fired. J.D.'s smile turned predatory. "You might find it a little difficult, however, since I own part of the place." Later, in her office, Dru faced him across her desk. "Are you totally crazy? I had to comp her dinner in the restaurant to smooth things over." "You did what?" The temperature in the room dropped twenty degrees. "J.D., please keep in mind that Star Lake Lodge prides itself on exceptional service—" "What kind of message does that send to our employees?" His hands slammed down on her desk, scattering papers. "You reward someone for abusing our staff?" The word 'our' hit Dru like a physical blow. He'd claimed the lodge, claimed the employees—claimed her, in a way. Standing this close, she could see the gold flecks in his hazel eyes, smell the clean scent of his soap mixed with something darker, more dangerous. "They're not our employees," she started, then caught her mistake. J.D.'s smile was sharp as broken glass. "Oh, yeah, sweetheart, they are. In fact, I'm not all that certain about the 'you' part of this equation. If I'm not mistaken, you're my employee as well." Heat flooded her face, but she held his stare. Later, after she'd made things right with Sean, after J.D. had stalked out with barely concealed fury, she sat alone in her office and pressed her palms to her flushed cheeks. He was arrogant, impossible, completely wrong for everything she'd built here. So why did her heart race every time he looked at her like that?

Chapter 3: Building Bonds: Integration into the Lawrence Family Circle

The canoe restoration became J.D.'s obsession. Dru would find him in the evenings, shirt off in the dying light, sanding the old cedar hull with the concentration of a master craftsman. Tate had taken to hanging around, chattering endlessly about the boat's progress. "Can we paint it red, J.D.? Red's the coolest color." "I was thinking red myself, buddy." Dru watched from her apartment window as her son soaked up male attention like a plant starved for sunlight. Tate's father had vanished the moment she'd announced her pregnancy, leaving her to raise their child alone. She'd managed fine—better than fine—but seeing Tate's face light up when J.D. explained boat-building techniques made her chest tight with emotions she didn't want to examine. Sophie invited J.D. to dinner with increasing frequency. Her aunt had always collected strays, but this felt different. Sophie would light up when J.D. complimented her cooking, would slip extra servings onto his plate when she thought no one was looking. "He's too thin," Sophie confided to Dru one evening. "And did you see how he scraped that bowl clean? Like he'd never tasted crème brûlée before." "Maybe he hadn't," Dru said quietly. That night, lying in her narrow bed, she thought about J.D.'s careful way of eating, how he'd pause sometimes mid-bite like he was memorizing the taste. She thought about the flowers Sophie left in his cabin, how his face had softened when he'd noticed them. Small kindnesses seemed to catch him off guard, as if he'd never learned to expect them. The family dynamic shifted around him like iron filings drawn to a magnet. Ben started including him in maintenance discussions, asking his opinion on repairs and improvements. Tate appointed himself J.D.'s apprentice, following him around with hammer and nails. But it was the quiet moments that undid Dru—catching J.D. listening to one of Tate's rambling stories with complete attention, or watching him help Sophie carry groceries with old-fashioned courtesy. He was integrating into their lives whether he intended to or not. And Dru was falling for him whether she intended to or not. The realization hit her one evening as she watched J.D. and Tate work on the canoe by lamplight. Tate said something that made J.D. laugh—really laugh, not the careful social smile he wore around guests. The sound rolled across the clearing warm and rich, and Dru felt her heart crack open. She was in love with him. Completely, irrevocably in love with a man who treated permanence like poison and trust like a luxury he couldn't afford.

Chapter 4: Shadows from Seattle: When the Past Threatens the Present

The canoe's maiden voyage should have been perfect. Early morning light painted the lake silver, and Tate bounced with excitement as J.D. loaded their gear. Dru watched her two favorite men fuss over paddle positions and weight distribution, her heart full of contentment. Then the water started seeping through the floorboards. "We're taking on water," Dru said, trying to keep alarm from her voice. J.D.'s face went grim as he turned the craft around. "Start bailing. There's a cup in the cooler." But the leak accelerated. The stern settled lower, water rushing in faster than they could bail. J.D. made the call with characteristic calm: "We're going in." The canoe flipped as they abandoned it. Dru saw the bow descending toward Tate, saw J.D. launch himself between the heavy wooden craft and her son's fragile skull. The sickening crack of impact echoed across the water. Later, after rescue, after bandages and explanations, J.D. examined the wreckage with Ben. His face turned to stone as he pointed out the deliberate cuts in the hull. "Someone sabotaged it," he said quietly. "Then painted over the damage." "Who would want to hurt you, son?" Ben asked. J.D.'s jaw worked. "Robbie Lankovich. His father went to prison because I testified against him. Kid's been making threats." But it wasn't just the canoe. Sophie took J.D.'s car to run an errand and nearly went over a cliff when the engine died—the gas tank siphoned dry. The pattern was clear: someone wanted J.D. dead, and anyone close to him was expendable collateral damage. That night, J.D. came to Dru's apartment with haunted eyes and a duffel bag. "I'm leaving," he said without preamble. The words hit her like ice water. "What?" "I thought I could start over here, but my past isn't done with me. I won't let it hurt you or Tate or your family." Dru felt panic rise in her throat. Not again. She wouldn't be abandoned again. "So you're saying you're leaving because you care for us?" His nod was curt, reluctant. "People who care for each other stick together," she said fiercely. "People who care for each other see to it that those they care for don't get hurt." But J.D.'s resolve cracked when she moved close, when she cupped his face in her hands and told him she loved him. The kiss that followed held desperation on both sides, the hunger of people who knew their time was running out. Later, tangled in her sheets with moonlight painting silver across their skin, J.D. held her like she was made of spun glass. "I have to go," he whispered against her hair. "Then you're a fool," Dru said, though her voice broke. "Because you could have had me, but you threw me away to satisfy your damn pride." In the morning, he was gone.

Chapter 5: Confrontation and Choice: Butch's Deadly Visit Forces a Decision

J.D. returned to his cabin to find a figure silhouetted against the window, a gun steady in familiar hands. "Hello, J.D." Butch Dickson stepped into the light, and twenty years of friendship crystallized into this single moment of betrayal. "Well, I'll be damned," J.D. said, sinking onto the couch edge. "I knew Robbie Lankovich didn't have the stones for this." Butch's laugh was bitter. "You thought Junior was behind this? Spending time in Pissville has cost you your edge, boy." The pieces fell together with sickening clarity. The convenience store robbery back in Seattle. The clerk who'd been shot. The alibi J.D. had provided because he'd owed Butch a debt from their youth. "You really did it," J.D. said quietly. "You shot that man." "He forced my hand!" Butch's voice cracked like a whip. "All he had to do was fork over the money, but he had to play hero. Guy practically begged to be killed." J.D. felt disgust rise in his throat. This was his oldest friend, the closest thing to family he'd ever known. And Butch was prepared to kill him to keep his secret safe. "Turn around," Butch ordered. "Forget it. You want to shoot me, you can damn well look me in the eye when you do it." Through the cabin's thin walls, J.D. heard a soft thud. Then the screen door exploded inward and Butch crumpled like a broken marionette, Dru standing behind him with a rock the size of a softball and the whitest face J.D. had ever seen. "Did I kill him?" she whispered. J.D. felt for a pulse, found it steady. "No. He'll live." He gathered the gun carefully, then pulled Dru into his arms. She was shaking like a leaf in a windstorm. "I heard him talking about shooting someone," she said against his chest. "I couldn't let him hurt you." The sheriff's deputy arrived within minutes, but not before Butch regained consciousness and made one last grab for Dru's ankle. J.D. kicked him away with savage satisfaction, pressing the gun barrel to his former friend's throat. "Give me one good reason why I shouldn't pull this trigger," J.D. said quietly. But even as Butch's eyes went wide with terror, J.D. knew he couldn't do it. That was the difference between them—J.D. had learned what mattered in life. Killing wasn't the answer, even when it would solve everything. As the deputy cuffed Butch and read him his rights, J.D. felt the last twenty years of his life crumble away. Seattle, the construction crews, the careful walls he'd built around his heart—all of it meaningless now. What mattered was the woman beside him, pale but determined. What mattered was the life they could build together if he had the courage to reach for it.

Chapter 6: Legal Reckoning: Facing the Consequences with Love's Support

The trip to Seattle stretched into ten days of depositions, statements, and legal maneuvering. Dru insisted on accompanying J.D., despite his protests. "We're in this together," she said simply, and something in her voice made argument impossible. The prosecutor's office was all glass and steel, nothing like the warm wood and stone of Star Lake Lodge. J.D. sat across from attorneys who looked like they'd never gotten their hands dirty, explaining how he'd provided an alibi for a killer without knowing the truth. "Mr. Carver," the district attorney said, "you understand that providing false testimony in a murder investigation is a serious crime?" "I understand that I believed my friend when he told me he was with his girlfriend that afternoon," J.D. replied evenly. "If I'd thought for one second he was involved in that robbery, I never would have lied for him." Dru squeezed his hand under the table, her wedding ring catching courthouse fluorescents. They'd married quietly before leaving Star Lake, a simple ceremony with just family present. She'd worn a blue dress that matched her eyes and carried wildflowers from Sophie's garden. "I'm taking your name," she'd told him afterward. "Tate wants to as well. We're going to be a real family, John David." Now, facing potential prison time, J.D. marveled at her faith. She sat through every meeting, every deposition, her quiet strength anchoring him when the system threatened to grind him under. The break came when Butch's girlfriend corroborated J.D.'s story. She'd lied initially to protect herself, but faced with murder charges, she finally admitted the truth. Butch had been with her during the robbery, exactly as he'd claimed. "Case closed," the prosecutor said, though he didn't look happy about it. "Mr. Carver, you're free to go. But you'll need to return for Mr. Dickson's trial." Outside the courthouse, Dru threw her arms around J.D.'s neck. "I told you," she said fiercely. "I told you we'd fight this." That night, in their Seattle hotel room, J.D. held his wife against his chest and felt the last walls around his heart crumble to dust. She'd stood by him through everything, never wavering, never doubting. "Ready to go home?" she asked. Home. The word still felt foreign on his tongue, but it was getting easier to say.

Chapter 7: Home Found: Marriage, Family, and True Belonging at Star Lake

The celebration at Ben and Sophie's house was simple—just family and close friends gathered around the old oak table, toasting J.D.'s freedom with Sophie's homemade wine. Tate had appointed himself official storyteller, regaling everyone with dramatically embellished accounts of his new stepfather's legal triumph. "And then the judge said, 'J.D. Carver, you're the most innocent man who ever lived!'" Tate proclaimed, waving his hands for emphasis. "That's not quite how it went, buddy," J.D. said, ruffling the boy's hair. But Tate's enthusiasm was infectious, and even J.D. found himself smiling. Later, as the party wound down, Tate pulled J.D. aside with the serious expression he wore for important conversations. "J.D.? When you and Mom got married... can I call you Dad now?" The words hit J.D. like a physical blow. This kid—this amazing, bright, fearless kid—wanted him for a father. The lump in his throat made speech impossible for several seconds. "You want to call me Dad?" he managed finally. Tate flushed, suddenly uncertain. "Forget it. It was a dumb idea." "Hell, no, I'm not going to forget it." J.D. pulled the boy against his side, voice rough with emotion. "I'd be honored, Tate. I can't tell you how honored I'd be." The smile that lit Tate's face could have powered the entire lodge. Now, months later, J.D. stood on the rebuilt porch of their cabin—no longer his, but theirs—watching Dru hang laundry on the line Sophie had insisted they needed. Domestic bliss, he supposed. Six months ago, the phrase would have made him break out in hives. "Daddy! Daddy, look!" Tate came racing around the cabin, clutching something in his cupped hands. The name still sent a jolt of fierce protectiveness through J.D.'s chest. "What've you got there, son?" "Baby rabbits! I found them by the woodshed. Can we keep them? Please?" J.D. looked at the tiny, helpless creatures, then at his stepson's eager face. A year ago, he'd been a drifter with nothing but a broken-down car and a pocketful of bitterness. Now he had a home, a family, a future stretching ahead like an endless promise. "We'll have to ask your mother," he said, which was parent-speak for 'probably not, but I'm not going to be the bad guy.' Tate whooped and ran toward Dru, who was already shaking her head with resigned amusement. J.D. watched his wife negotiate with their son, her hands gesturing as she explained why wild rabbits needed to stay wild. The evening light caught in her hair, turned her skin golden. She'd changed his entire world without even trying, simply by refusing to let him walk away from happiness. J.D. pulled Edwina's pocket watch from his jeans, studying the worn gold case. He'd carried it for months now, no longer a reminder of betrayal but of the love that had brought him here. Edwina had known what she was doing when she'd left him Star Lake Lodge. She'd given him more than property—she'd given him a chance at the life he'd never dared imagine. Tate's laughter echoed across the clearing as Dru scooped him up in a hug. The sound wrapped around J.D.'s heart like a blessing, like coming home after a lifetime of wandering. He clicked the watch closed and slipped it back into his pocket, then walked toward his family.

Summary

The journey from drifter to family man transformed J.D. Carver in ways he'd never imagined possible. The man who'd arrived at Star Lake Lodge with nothing but suspicious wariness and painful memories had found something worth more than gold—unconditional love and unwavering loyalty. Dru Lawrence hadn't just offered him her heart; she'd fought for his freedom, stood by him through legal battles, and refused to let him sacrifice their happiness for misguided nobility. Together with Tate, they'd forged the kind of family J.D. had witnessed from the outside but never believed he could possess. Star Lake Lodge continued to thrive under their joint stewardship, its rustic elegance enhanced by J.D.'s careful craftsmanship and Dru's business acumen. But the real transformation wasn't in the restored buildings or improved facilities—it was in the laughter echoing through halls that had witnessed four generations of Lawrence family life. J.D. had finally learned the most important lesson of all: sometimes the thing you've spent your life running from is exactly what you need to become whole. Love doesn't weaken a man—it gives him something worth fighting for, something worth staying for, something worth calling home.

About Author

Loading

Susan Andersen

The author explores the dynamics of growing up surrounded by a predominantly male household, where her experiences of living with two brothers, her father, and grandfather shaped her worldview. This upbringing, characterized by the constant challenge of maintaining balance in the "testosterone pool," offers insights into familial relationships and gender dynamics. Her narrative highlights the protective yet competitive nature of having brothers, revealing both the comfort and chaos they brought into her life. Despite the overwhelming male presence, she managed to carve out her own identity and agency, demonstrating resilience and adaptability.\n\nHer writing method interlaces personal anecdotes with broader reflections on gender roles, showcasing a blend of humor and sincerity. The story of her household reveals how the small details, like the battle over the toilet seat, symbolize larger themes of negotiation and compromise within family life. The author emphasizes that growing up in such an environment can be both a trial and a blessing, portraying the dual nature of familial bonds. This nuanced portrayal provides readers with a deeper understanding of how family dynamics influence personal growth and perceptions of gender roles.\n\nThis brief bio serves those who seek to understand the complexities of family life through the lens of personal narrative. Her work resonates with readers who appreciate stories that balance humor with poignant reflections, offering both entertainment and insight. By sharing her experiences, the author invites others to reflect on their familial relationships and the subtle negotiations that occur within them. Her narrative not only entertains but also prompts readers to consider the impact of their upbringing on their own identities and relationships.

Read more