All the Missing Girls

All the Missing Girls Plot Summary

Introduction

# Echoes in the Woods: The Ghosts We Leave Behind Ten years. That's how long Nicolette Farrell stayed away from Cooley Ridge, building a life in Philadelphia where no one knew her story. But when her brother calls about their father's failing memory and mounting debts, she's forced to return to the North Carolina mountains that swallowed her best friend whole. The drive south feels like traveling backward through time, each mile stripping away the woman she's become to reveal the eighteen-year-old girl who fled after Corinne Prescott vanished without a trace. Now another young woman has disappeared from these same woods. Annaleise Carter, twenty-three, last seen walking into the forest behind Nic's childhood home. The missing posters line the telephone poles like ghosts made paper, amber eyes staring out from every storefront window. Some places never let you go, Nic realizes as she pulls into her childhood driveway. They wait patiently for your return, knowing that eventually, everyone comes home to face the secrets they left buried in the dark.

Chapter 1: Reluctant Return: Coming Home to Buried Secrets

The house looks smaller than memory painted it, white siding weathered gray in places where the mountain humidity has worked its slow magic. Daniel emerges from the garage, dirt streaking his bare chest, his face more angular than she remembers. Ten years of responsibility have carved new lines around his eyes, the weight of holding everything together while she built her escape route north. His pregnant wife Laura waves from the kitchen window, her belly round with their first child. They've been managing their father's decline and the slow decay of the family home, keeping vigil while Nic played at being someone else in a city that never asked uncomfortable questions about her past. Inside, the house holds ghosts in every corner. Dust motes dance in afternoon light, and everything feels half-there in the golden glow. Her old room remains exactly as she left it, yellow comforter rumpled at the foot of the bed. But something's wrong. Pictures have been removed from the walls, leaving pale rectangles on faded paint. Shoe boxes that lived high in her closet now sit stacked in the corner. At Grand Pines nursing home, their father Patrick drums his fingers on the cafeteria table in rhythms that match his scattered thoughts. When Nic sits across from him, his eyes light with recognition that feels like a small miracle these days. "I need to talk to you," he says, squeezing her hand with surprising strength. "That girl. I saw that girl." The words from his letter hang between them like smoke. His mind drifts between decades, but his fear feels immediate and real. "The woods have eyes," he whispers, glancing around the room with paranoid intensity. That evening, Tyler Ellison appears at her door like a ghost made flesh. Her high school boyfriend has grown into his frame, hands rough from construction work, blue eyes still holding that dangerous intensity that once made her believe in forever. The pull between them is immediate and treacherous, a gravitational force threatening to drag her back into the orbit of the girl she used to be.

Chapter 2: History Repeats: When the Past Refuses to Stay Dead

The call comes while Nic is upstairs, Daniel's voice tight with urgency cutting through the morning quiet. "Tell me where you are," he demands, engine noise roaring behind his words. Through her window, she watches Tyler approach the back door, his work boots caked with mud, his entire body trembling with barely contained panic. "Get out. Now," Daniel commands, but it's too late. Tyler is already inside, dirt falling from his clothes onto the kitchen floor, his hands shaking as he grips a chair for support. There's dried blood between his thumb and forefinger, yellow pollen clinging to his pants like evidence of something terrible. "I'm running out of time, Nic." His brown eyes are wild, unfocused. In the distance, a siren begins its high-pitched wail, growing closer with each heartbeat. "They found a body at Johnson Farm." The sunflower field. The same place where she and Corinne had posed for photographs years ago, spinning until they blurred like ghosts in Bailey's long-exposure shots. Now it's a crime scene, and Tyler stands before her covered in earth and pollen, looking like a man who's been digging graves. Detective Charles arrives from the state bureau with questions that cut too close to home. Young and ambitious, he treats the case like a puzzle to be solved rather than lives hanging in the balance. His notepad fills with familiar names. Tyler, Daniel, Jackson Porter. The same names that circled around Corinne's disappearance like vultures ten years ago. The body isn't Annaleise Carter. It's older, much older. Bones wrapped in fabric that time has begun to claim. But the discovery sends shockwaves through Cooley Ridge, awakening memories that have been buried for a decade. The investigation machinery grinds back to life, and suddenly they're all suspects again, playing the same roles they performed when they were barely adults. At Kelly's Pub, Jackson Porter serves drinks with steady hands that were once examined for scratches, for signs of violence. His tattoos ripple as he wipes down the bar, poetry and prose crawling up his forearms like confessions. He'd been Corinne's boyfriend, the obvious suspect, the one everyone whispered about in the aftermath.

Chapter 3: Photographs in the Dark: Blackmail and Hidden Truth

The knock comes after midnight, soft and insistent against Nic's back door. Annaleise Carter stands in the darkness holding an envelope, her pale hair catching moonlight like spun silver. She's not the timid girl from high school anymore, but something harder and more desperate. A woman who has learned to weaponize her invisibility. The photographs spill across the kitchen table like accusations made flesh. Grainy, dark images taken with a telephoto lens, enhanced by software that can pull secrets from shadows. They show the back porch of this house ten years ago. A bundle wrapped in a blanket, bronze hair spilling from dark fabric. The unmistakable shape of a body, and in the corner of the frame, a shadow that could be anyone. "I've always had them," Annaleise explains with the calm of someone who has rehearsed this moment. "I was playing with my new camera the night Corinne disappeared, trying to figure out the night settings. Your house always seemed haunted to me through the trees." She had been thirteen then, invisible and ignored, but cameras see everything. The blackmail note is typed and businesslike. Ten thousand to stay quiet, twenty thousand for the flash drive containing the originals. Annaleise has been bleeding Nic's father for years, his confusion making him an easy mark. She needs a way out of Cooley Ridge, away from the suffocating weight of small-town expectations. Nic stares at the images, her world tilting on its axis. The body on her porch, the shadow in the corner, the implications spreading like poison through her carefully constructed new life. Annaleise takes her engagement ring as insurance, sliding the two-carat diamond onto her finger like a promise of payment to come. "Two weeks," she says, and disappears back into the darkness from which she came. The photographs burn in the fireplace, but the images remain seared into Nic's memory. Corinne Prescott, reduced to shadows and speculation, her death becoming currency in a transaction she never consented to. The past refuses to stay buried, clawing its way back to the surface with interest compounded over a decade of silence.

Chapter 4: The Night Everything Changed: Corinne's Final Moments

Time becomes fluid in Cooley Ridge, past and present bleeding together like watercolors in rain. Nic finds herself working backward through the night Corinne disappeared, each memory a piece of a puzzle she's spent ten years trying to forget. The county fair, the Ferris wheel, the dare that changed everything. She remembers Corinne's cold fingers at her elbows, her breath smelling of spearmint gum and whispered secrets. "Jump," Corinne had said at the top of the Ferris wheel, daring Nic to climb outside the safety of their cart. But it wasn't the height that terrified her. It was the look in Corinne's eyes, the darkness that lived beneath her golden surface. The fight with Daniel came later, his fist connecting with her cheek in full view of the crowd. Tyler's retaliation, swift and protective, his knuckles splitting against her brother's jaw. The pregnancy test in Corinne's bathroom two days before, blue lines promising a future she wasn't ready for. All of it connected by invisible threads, a web of cause and effect leading inevitably to that dark road outside town. Tyler's truck, Nic behind the wheel because his hand was injured. Corinne standing in the headlights with her thumb out, then stepping deliberately into their path. The screech of brakes, the world spinning sideways, the terrible silence that followed. They searched for her body in the darkness, calling her name into the void, but found nothing. Tyler made a choice that night, telling Nic she hadn't killed anyone, that Corinne had jumped out of the way and was playing one of her cruel games. But games end, and Corinne never came home. The investigation that followed tore the town apart, suspicion falling on everyone who had ever loved or hated her. The truth was simpler and more terrible than any of them wanted to admit. Corinne Prescott had thrown herself in front of a truck driven by her best friend, and that friend had left her dying on the side of the road. Some secrets are too heavy for one person to carry, so they become shared burdens, distributed among the living like pieces of a broken mirror.

Chapter 5: Blood in the Sunflowers: Silencing the Witness

The call comes from Tyler, his voice tight with panic cutting through the morning air. "They found Annaleise. She's dead." The body lies in Johnson Farm's sunflower field, a letter tucked into her waistband directing police to look for Corinne Prescott's remains on the Farrell property. The net is closing, ten years of carefully maintained silence about to be shattered by a dead woman's final accusation. Nic understands with crystalline clarity what must have happened. Annaleise had called Laura from the motel where she'd taken refuge, trying to turn Daniel's wife against him with stories of murder and cover-up. But Laura was eight months pregnant with a future she refused to let anyone destroy. She had picked up their father's gun and driven Annaleise to that field of sunflowers. The sirens grow louder as Tyler stands in her kitchen, covered in pollen from the crime scene, his truck placing him at the location where Annaleise died. He had gone looking for Nic's stolen ring, trying to tie up one last loose end before running. But there's no running from this anymore. The past has finally caught up with all of them. Detective Charles pushes harder now, asking pointed questions about phone calls and confrontations, about patterns that echo Corinne's case with disturbing precision. The investigation is methodically destroying what remains of their relationships, turning friends into suspects, love into liability. At the house, Nic finds evidence that someone has been searching through her father's belongings, rifling through boxes of old papers and teaching materials. The back door's broken lock makes it impossible to secure the house, and she begins to feel watched, followed, hunted by something that moves through the woods with predatory patience. The search warrant yields nothing because there's nothing left to find. Daniel moved Corinne's body years ago, and Laura disposed of the gun where it will never be recovered. The investigation stalls on lack of evidence, on a town that has learned to keep its secrets, on the simple fact that sometimes the guilty go unpunished and the innocent carry the weight of crimes they didn't commit.

Chapter 6: Choosing Silence: Family Over Justice

Nic makes her decision in the space between heartbeats. She pulls Tyler into the shower as the police cars arrive, creating the alibi he needs, the story they've all been expecting. The jealous ex-girlfriend, the rekindled romance, the motive that makes sense to minds that need simple explanations for complex tragedies. She sacrifices her engagement, her carefully constructed life, her future with Everett to save the boy who once promised to love her forever. The investigation crumbles like old paper in the mountain humidity. Without physical evidence, without cooperative witnesses, without anything more substantial than a dead woman's accusations, the case dissolves into speculation and small-town gossip. Detective Charles returns to the state capital, frustrated by a wall of silence that seems impenetrable. Officer Fraize files his reports and moves on to crimes that might actually be solved. The truth about both Corinne Prescott and Annaleise Carter dies with them, buried beneath the weight of small-town justice and mutual protection. Laura gives birth to a daughter they name Shana, after Nic's mother. She holds the baby with steady hands that show no tremor, no sign of the violence they committed in a field of sunflowers. Daniel dotes on his wife and child, grateful for the family that Laura killed to protect. Nic brings their father home from the memory care facility, converting the garage into a living space where he can exist in whatever timeline feels most real to him. Some days he knows her, some days he calls her by her mother's name, but he's surrounded by familiar walls and the scent of home. The pregnancy test shows two pink lines, just like the one in Corinne's bathroom ten years ago. This time Nic doesn't run. This time she lets Tyler hold her as she cries, lets him promise that everything will be different, that their child will grow up in a house full of love instead of secrets. They're older now, scarred by experience, but maybe that's what it takes to build something lasting from the wreckage of the past.

Chapter 7: Living Among Ghosts: The Price of Staying Home

Three months later, Nic wakes in her childhood bedroom to the sound of Tyler making coffee in the kitchen below. Her father sits at the table reading Nabokov, lost in a world where her mother is still alive and the future stretches ahead like an unwritten page. The morning light filters through windows that have watched three generations of Farrells live and love and lose everything that matters. The storage unit in Philadelphia holds the remnants of her other life, painted furniture and professional clothes that belong to a woman who no longer exists. When the rent comes due and no one answers the phone, they'll auction it all off or throw it in a dumpster. That person was always a ghost anyway, a carefully constructed fiction designed to hide the girl who killed her best friend. Cooley Ridge has claimed her completely now, drawn her back into its orbit of shared secrets and mutual protection. The town operates on an economy of silence, where debts are paid in blood and loyalty, where the guilty protect each other because they understand that survival depends on solidarity. The baby grows inside her like a promise of redemption, a chance to build something clean from the wreckage of the past. Tyler's hands are gentle on her belly, his voice soft as he talks to the child who will never know the full truth about how they came to exist. Some stories are too heavy for small shoulders, too dark for innocent ears. At night, when sleep won't come, Nic sometimes sees Corinne in the shadows at the foot of her bed. Not the broken girl from the photographs, but the golden creature who once dared her to jump from a Ferris wheel, who whispered secrets in the darkness, who loved and hated with equal intensity. She's part of the house now, woven into its foundation like rebar. The woods behind the house whisper with the voices of all the girls who never made it home, all the secrets buried beneath decades of fallen leaves. Nic listens to their chorus as she falls asleep, Tyler's arm around her waist, their child safe in the darkness of her womb. She's paid her debts in full, traded her freedom for his, her future for their past.

Summary

Home, Nic learns, is not a place you can escape but a gravity you carry within you, pulling you back no matter how far you travel or how much you change. It's the weight of shared secrets and mutual protection, the understanding that some truths are too dangerous to survive in the light. Cooley Ridge has taught her that love and loyalty are measured not in words but in the depths of silence you're willing to maintain, the lies you're willing to tell, the prices you're willing to pay. The investigation into Annaleise Carter's death remains officially open but practically abandoned, filed away with all the other mysteries that small towns accumulate like sediment. The truth about Corinne Prescott dies with her, buried beneath a decade of carefully constructed fiction and the simple fact that sometimes the guilty go unpunished while the innocent carry burdens they never chose. In the end, she has traded everything she built in Philadelphia for the chance to stay among the ghosts that shaped her, to raise her child in the shadow of the girl she killed and the woman who died trying to expose her. The woods will keep their secrets, the dead will rest uneasily in their unmarked graves, and life will continue in the strange, twisted way it always has in places where the past refuses to stay buried.

About Author

Loading

Megan Miranda

Miranda delves into the intricacies of human relationships through suspenseful narratives that keep readers on the edge of their seats. Her books often delve into the themes of memory and identity, posing questions about how well we truly know those around us. In "The Last House Guest," selected for Reese Witherspoon's Book Club, Miranda uses a tight-knit community as a backdrop to explore secrets and betrayal, while "All the Missing Girls" innovatively unfolds its story in reverse chronological order to heighten suspense. Her method of intertwining complex character development with gripping plots sets her apart in the thriller genre.\n\nFor readers seeking a deep dive into the darker aspects of human nature, Miranda's work offers a compelling exploration of trust and deception. The author skillfully balances intricate plotlines with a keen insight into the human psyche, making her books not only page-turners but also thoughtful reflections on personal and social dynamics. As Miranda continues to captivate her audience with titles like "The Only Survivors" and the anticipated "You Belong Here," her bio underscores a consistent theme of unraveling mysteries that challenge perceptions. Therefore, her stories appeal not only to thriller enthusiasts but also to those interested in the complexities of interpersonal relationships.\n\nBy situating her narratives in both familiar and eerie settings, Miranda enhances the psychological tension that defines her work. Her academic background from MIT may inform the meticulous structure of her storytelling, providing a logical underpinning to the mysteries she constructs. Fans of psychological thrillers will find her books a rewarding experience, as they offer not just entertainment but a profound examination of the human condition. Through her carefully crafted plots and deep character insights, Miranda continues to shape the genre, ensuring her place as a prominent voice in contemporary fiction.

Read more