The Art of Possibility

The Art of Possibility Plot Summary

Introduction

Imagine a classroom filled with anxious music students preparing for their final assessment. The tension is palpable as they worry about grades, rankings, and potentially harsh judgments from their professor. Then something unexpected happens. Their instructor announces, "Each of you will get an A for this course. The only requirement is that you write me a letter, dated from the end of the semester, explaining why you deserved that A." The atmosphere transforms instantly. Students who moments ago were competitors now share ideas freely. Their focus shifts from survival to possibility. This scene exemplifies the profound shift in perspective that can occur when we change our mental frameworks. Most of us live within self-imposed constraints, viewing life through lenses of scarcity, competition, and measurement. We believe certain things are fixed or impossible. Yet what if these limitations exist only in our minds? What if we could step into a universe of possibility where connection replaces competition, contribution replaces achievement, and abundance replaces scarcity? Through compelling stories drawn from music, business, education, and personal relationships, we discover how radically new perspectives can transform ordinary situations into extraordinary opportunities for fulfillment, creativity, and meaningful connection with others.

Chapter 1: Reimagining Reality: The Power of 'It's All Invented'

A shoe factory sends two marketing scouts to a remote region of Africa to study the prospects for expanding business. One sends back a telegram saying, "SITUATION HOPELESS STOP NO ONE WEARS SHOES." The other writes back triumphantly, "GLORIOUS BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY STOP THEY HAVE NO SHOES." The same reality, yet two entirely different stories. To the first scout, barefoot villagers signaled a dead end. To the second, they represented untapped potential. Neither scout was objectively "right" - each simply constructed a different narrative from the same observations. This perfectly illustrates one of the book's foundational concepts: "It's all invented." This phrase doesn't suggest we can conjure physical objects from thin air. Rather, it reveals that the meanings, limitations, and possibilities we perceive are largely constructions of our minds. Scientific research confirms this. Our brains don't passively record reality like cameras. Instead, they actively create models of the world based on limited sensory input and past experiences. A frog's visual system, for instance, only detects four types of phenomena: clear lines of contrast, sudden changes in illumination, moving outlines, and small dark objects. It cannot see colors or static scenes - only what it needs for survival. Human perception works similarly, though with greater complexity. We see what our mental frameworks allow us to see. Consider the classic nine-dot puzzle, where people struggle to connect all dots with four straight lines because they unconsciously impose an invisible boundary around the dots. The solution requires drawing lines beyond this assumed border - literally "thinking outside the box." Once we understand that our perceptions and limitations are largely invented, we gain the freedom to invent different interpretations that serve us better. We can ask: "What assumption am I making that I'm not aware I'm making? What might I now invent that would give me other choices?" This awareness doesn't just change how we see problems - it transforms our very experience of reality, opening doors to possibilities previously invisible to us.

Chapter 2: Giving an A: Liberating Others from Measurement

"Each student in this class will get an A for the course," announces Ben Zander to his graduate music students at the New England Conservatory. "However, there is one requirement: Sometime during the next two weeks, you must write me a letter dated next May, which begins with the words, 'Dear Mr. Zander, I got my A because...' In this letter, you are to tell, in as much detail as you can, the story of what will have happened to you by next May that is in line with this extraordinary grade." This unconventional approach transformed the classroom atmosphere. One Korean flute player wrote: "I received my grade A because I worked hard and thought hard about myself taking your class, and the result was absolutely tremendous. I became a new person. I used to be so negative for almost everything even before trying. Now I find myself happier than before. I couldn't accept my mistakes about a year ago, and after every mistake I blamed myself, but now, I enjoy making mistakes and I really learn from these mistakes." Another student, a Taiwanese musician who had always ranked near the bottom of his class, shared his revelation: "In Taiwan, I was Number 68 out of 70 students. I come to Boston and Mr. Zander says I am an A. Very confusing. I walk about, three weeks, very confused. I am Number 68, but Mr. Zander says I am an A student... I am Number 68, but Mr. Zander says I am an A. One day I discover much happier A than Number 68. So I decide I am an A." Giving an A isn't about eliminating standards or pretending everyone is equally skilled. It's about seeing people as their potential selves rather than through the lens of past performance or current limitations. It's like Michelangelo's approach to sculpture - he believed the beautiful statue already existed within the marble block; his job was merely to remove the excess stone to reveal it. This practice fundamentally shifts relationships. When we give someone an A, we speak to them not from judgment but from a place of respect that gives them room to realize themselves. We look for their hidden potential rather than focusing on their shortcomings. The A isn't an expectation to live up to but a possibility to live into. And remarkably, when we view others this way, they often rise to meet our vision of them - not because they fear disappointing us, but because we've created a space where their best self can emerge naturally.

Chapter 3: Being a Contribution: Moving Beyond Success and Failure

A woman strolls along a beach at dawn, bending down repeatedly to throw something into the sea. Drawing closer, a man sees she's rescuing stranded starfish, tossing them back into the water one by one. "There are stranded starfish as far as the eye can see," he scoffs. "What difference can saving a few possibly make?" Smiling serenely, she bends down, tosses another starfish into the waves, and replies, "It certainly makes a difference to this one." This simple story captures the essence of the contribution game - a radical alternative to the success/failure paradigm that dominates our achievement-oriented culture. For Benjamin Zander, this shift came after a profound personal crisis. When his marriage ended unexpectedly, he realized how much anxiety and strain the pursuit of "success" had created in his life. "The drive to be successful and the fear of failure are, like the head and tail of a coin, inseparably linked," he reflects. "They goaded me on to unusual efforts and caused me, and those around me, considerable suffering." In this moment of clarity, he invented a new game called "I am a contribution." Unlike success and failure, contribution has no opposite - it's not arrived at by comparison. The question "Is it enough?" disappears, replaced by the joyful inquiry: "How will I be a contribution today?" When playing this game, there's no better orchestra than the one he's conducting, no better person to be with than whoever he's with. Life becomes about giving rather than getting. In one particularly moving example, Zander describes visiting a Jewish home for the elderly, reluctantly fulfilling a commitment despite his packed schedule. There, he met Sarah, an 83-year-old woman who sat stubbornly in the fifth row, refusing to move forward when asked. "Who knows, Sarah," Zander challenged playfully, "if you change your seat maybe something new will happen today." Despite her initial resistance, Sarah moved up one row. Later, after an unexpectedly moving two-hour session filled with music, stories, and shared laughter, Sarah stood up, raised her fist, and declared, "You ain't seen nothing yet! I just got started!" Contribution transforms our relationship with others and ourselves. When we define ourselves as contributors rather than competitors, we discover that life isn't about measuring up or falling short - it's about making a difference, however small. Like ripples from a pebble in a pond, our contributions create waves of possibility that extend far beyond what we can see or measure.

Chapter 4: The Central Self: Transcending the Calculating Mind

At the Holocaust Memorial in Boston, five pillars tell stories of suffering and cruelty. But the sixth pillar shares something different - a memory from Auschwitz recounted by Guerda Weissman Kline about her friend Ilse, a six-year-old girl. One day, Ilse found a single raspberry somewhere in the camp. She carried it all day in her pocket, and in the evening, her eyes shining with happiness, presented it to Guerda on a leaf. "Imagine a world," writes Guerda, "in which your entire possession is one raspberry, and you give it to your friend." This moving story illuminates what the authors call our "central self" - the generative, creative core of our being capable of profound generosity and connection. But another aspect of ourselves often dominates our lives: the calculating self. This aspect develops as a survival strategy in childhood, learning to assess where power lies and what we must do to be accepted. Like a child positioning herself in a family, it continually seeks advantage, control, and security. The authors illustrate this distinction through the story of June, a woman who had left her husband Mark because she found him self-absorbed and narcissistic. When her therapy group challenged her to "Have the Best Sex Ever" as an exercise, June initially resisted, certain that reconnecting with Mark was impossible. But then she remembered "Rule Number 6" - don't take yourself so seriously - and asked herself: "What would have to change to make this possible?" Her automatic answer was that Mark would have to change, but she suddenly realized the absurdity of this position. "Why can't you have the Best Sex Ever with a self-centered guy?" she wondered. Lightening up about her grievances, she called Mark and invited herself over. To her surprise, he responded with unexpected sensitivity. Their evening together was magical, and June realized that her rigid diagnosis of Mark had become a self-fulfilling prophecy. By letting go of her calculating self's need to be right, she accessed her central self's capacity for connection. The calculating self creates divisions, constantly comparing and positioning itself against others. But our central self recognizes our fundamental interconnectedness. When we operate from this deeper place, we experience what happened when a facilitator helped two business partners resolve their deadlocked conflict: "Like a tap to a kaleidoscope that shifts identical pieces of glass into different patterns, the scene changed before our eyes from bankruptcy to abundance with just the slightest nudge to the frame."

Chapter 5: Rule Number 6: Lightening Up to Transform Relationships

Two prime ministers are meeting to discuss affairs of state when a man bursts in, apoplectic with fury, shouting and banging his fist on the desk. The resident prime minister calmly says, "Peter, kindly remember Rule Number 6," whereupon Peter instantly calms down, apologizes, and withdraws. When this happens again with another interruption, the visiting prime minister asks about this remarkable rule. "Very simple," replies his colleague. "Rule Number 6 is 'Don't take yourself so g—damn seriously.'" "Ah," says the visitor, "that is a fine rule. And what are the other rules?" "There aren't any." This humorous story captures a transformative practice that can defuse tension and open new possibilities in even the most challenging situations. When Benjamin Zander shared this story with executives at a European company, they embraced it so completely that they placed "Remember Rule Number 6" plaques on every manager's desk - with the message facing both ways. The company president later reported that this simple reminder had transformed their corporate culture. The practice works by helping us recognize and step back from our "calculating self" - the aspect of our personality focused on survival, comparison, and control. This self takes everything personally and very seriously indeed. When we invoke Rule Number 6, we create distance from this reactive part of ourselves and access what the authors call our "central self" - the more expansive, creative, and generous aspect of our nature. In a dramatic demonstration of this principle, Zander describes coaching a talented but self-important tenor named Jeffrey who was preparing to sing Schubert's "Spring Dream" from Die Winterreise. Despite the music's delicate, melancholy nature, Jeffrey sang with booming, self-conscious virtuosity - "Pure Jeffrey, taking himself very seriously." For forty-five minutes, Zander worked to help Jeffrey move beyond his ego and connect with the music's vulnerable essence. As each layer of pride was peeled away, Jeffrey's voice lost its polished veneer and revealed the human soul beneath. At the final words, "When will I have my lover in my arms again?" his voice, now almost inaudible, touched everyone present. Even the cameraman filming the session was moved to tears, later confessing: "When I was sent on this job from London, I had no idea that this music shit was about my life." When we take ourselves less seriously, paradoxically, we create more meaningful connections with others. By lightening up about our positions, opinions, and self-importance, we open space for authenticity and vulnerability. Rule Number 6 doesn't diminish our effectiveness - it enhances it by freeing us from the prison of our own egos.

Chapter 6: Creating Frameworks for Possibility: Leadership Transformed

When Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. delivered his famous "I have a dream" speech in Washington, D.C., he wasn't merely addressing the immediate crowd. He was speaking to a fundamental human desire shared by everyone - perpetrators and victims, whites and blacks, people on all sides of the issues. King demonstrated through his words and his life that dreaming can make a difference, creating frameworks that bring forth possibility even in the face of seemingly intractable problems. The authors suggest that this ability - to maintain clarity and stand confidently in possibility despite fierce competition, short-term pressures, and widespread fear - represents the foremost challenge for leaders today. Such leadership isn't about domination or control but about creating environments where possibility can flourish. Anyone can exercise this kind of leadership, whether they're a CEO or employee, teacher or student, friend or lover. This practice was powerfully illustrated when Benjamin Zander visited Eastlea School, a "failing" institution in London's toughest neighborhood. After his initial visit created unexpected enthusiasm among the students, he returned with the entire Philharmonia Orchestra. During a demonstration of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, Zander broke down the complex piece by having the orchestra add one instrumental voice at a time - cellos, then violas, then bassoon and clarinet, and so on. "How many of you could hear seven voices?" he asked after all instruments were playing. Remarkably, nearly all 900 students raised their hands. Then, noticing a hyperactive ten-year-old boy moving to the rhythm, Zander invited him to conduct. The child took the podium and, to everyone's amazement, led the world-class orchestra with powerful, natural gestures. That night, all of Britain watched on television as young Anthony conducted the Philharmonia in the finale of Beethoven's Fifth. What made this transformation possible wasn't just Zander's technical expertise, but his ability to create a framework that brought forth possibility. Instead of seeing "problem students" from a "failing school," he saw young people eager to connect with great music. Instead of focusing on obstacles, he created an environment where passion and participation could flourish. The practice of framing possibility involves making new distinctions that substitute for frameworks generating downward spirals, then embodying these distinctions so completely that they become the context for life around you. Unlike traditional vision statements focused on competition and achievement, true frameworks for possibility articulate something fundamental to humankind - something no one could respond to by asking, "What about me?"

Chapter 7: Telling the WE Story: Building Collective Meaning

Walter Zander, Benjamin's father, was invited to speak to American students about the conflict between Jews and Arabs. Over a candlelit dinner, he began by describing the whole sweep of Jewish history - from Abraham through medieval times to the Holocaust - bringing the saga to rest on the tiny sliver of land called Palestine in 1947. Then, with equal passion and detail, he narrated the entire history of the Arab people - their sciences, arts, and legendary courtesy - tracing their story to the same piece of land at the same moment in history. Struck by this parallel telling, one student exclaimed, "What a wonderful opportunity! What a privilege for both those peoples to share that land and that history!" This balanced narrative exemplifies what the authors call "the WE story" - an approach to conflict that transcends the usual divisions between "us" and "them." Rather than seeing relationships as negotiations between separate entities with fixed wants, this practice recognizes a new entity that emerges between people - the WE. This entity represents our fundamental connectedness and the possibility of evolution beyond entrenched positions. The WE practice was dramatically illustrated when a therapist intervened in a heated conflict between a husband and wife on the verge of separation. As the wife howled at her husband, "YOU DON'T LOVE ME!" the therapist found herself shouting back, "Who could love you when you act like this?" Horrified by her outburst, she suddenly had an insight: "But it's not you speaking. It is something else: Revenge. Revenge is speaking in your voice." By externalizing the destructive emotion as a separate entity - not as part of the wife's identity - she created a framework where compassion could flow again. A similar approach informed South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission after apartheid ended. Instead of pursuing retribution, the commission offered amnesty to those who fully disclosed their political crimes. This framework wasn't about denying justice but about creating possibility through truth-telling. As one young woman realized after hearing a policeman confess to killing her mother: "The TRC was never supposed to be about justice; it's about the truth." The practice involves three steps: telling the WE story - the story of our connectedness; listening for the emerging entity; and asking questions like "What do WE want to have happen here?" and "What's best for US?" These questions aren't about compromise but about finding a way forward that honors the wholeness of everyone involved.

Summary

The Art of Possibility invites us to transform our lives by radically shifting our perceptions. Through practices like "It's All Invented," we recognize that most limitations exist only in our minds, freeing us to create more empowering interpretations of reality. By "Giving an A" to others, we see them not as they have performed in the past but as the magnificent beings they could become. When we define ourselves as "Being a Contribution" rather than seeking success, we escape the anxiety of comparison and find joy in making a difference. These transformative practices work because they address our deepest human longings: to connect authentically with others, to express our creativity, and to contribute meaningfully to the world. Whether conducting an orchestra, resolving business conflicts, or navigating personal relationships, the same principles apply. We can step beyond the calculating self that constantly positions for advantage into the central self that recognizes our fundamental connectedness. We can create frameworks for possibility that inspire collective action, and tell the WE story that transcends divisive narratives. As Zander demonstrates with the young boy who conducted the Philharmonia Orchestra, extraordinary potential exists within each of us - waiting only for the right conditions to emerge. The universe of possibility is always available; we need only the courage to step into it.

About Author

Loading...

Rosamund Stone Zander

Read more