The Worst Best Man

The Worst Best Man Plot Summary

Introduction

# Hearts Rewritten: When Past Shadows Meet New Beginnings The text message arrives like a death sentence on Max Hartley's phone screen. His older brother Andrew has just bailed on his wedding, leaving Max to face the unthinkable task of breaking the news to Carolina Santos—a woman whose life he's about to destroy. Three years later, fate delivers its twisted sense of humor when Max walks into a conference room expecting a routine business meeting, only to come face to face with the woman whose wedding day he helped destroy. Lina Santos has transformed herself from jilted bride to successful wedding planner, but when she sees Max and Andrew together, panic flickers across her features. In a moment of pure desperation, she makes a choice that will complicate everything—she pretends not to know them. What follows is a dangerous game of deception, professional competition, and undeniable attraction that threatens to unravel the carefully constructed walls both have built around their hearts.

Chapter 1: The Weight of Past Mistakes

The Cartwright Hotel's gleaming conference room feels smaller with each passing second. Rebecca Cartwright, sharp-eyed and decisive, explains the position that could change everything for Lina Santos. The hotel group wants to establish itself as a premier wedding destination, and they need an experienced coordinator to make it happen. It's the opportunity Lina has dreamed of—steady income, prestige, and freedom from the cramped office space she's about to lose. But Andrew Hartley sits across from her like a ghost made flesh, his familiar features now carrying the weight of their shared history. Max, younger and more intense than she remembered from that disastrous wedding day, keeps shooting her questioning glances. The brothers are both vying for the marketing contract that would accompany her potential position, turning what should be a straightforward interview into a complex triangle of professional competition and personal landmines. When Rebecca asks about her experience with high-end venues, Lina's voice doesn't waver. She's learned to compartmentalize pain, to function even when her world tilts off its axis. Andrew's presence is a test of every defense mechanism she's built over three years of rebuilding her life from the ashes of public humiliation. The meeting ends with handshakes and promises to be in touch. As the brothers file out, Max lingers for a heartbeat longer than necessary. "Interesting approach," he murmurs, and Lina can't tell if it's a threat or an acknowledgment of her survival instincts. Outside the hotel, she sits in her aging Volvo and allows herself exactly sixty seconds to feel the full weight of what just happened. Then she starts the engine and drives toward an uncertain future, knowing she's just lit a fuse on a bomb she can't defuse.

Chapter 2: Pretending to Be Strangers

Max Hartley has always lived in his older brother's shadow, but he's never resented it quite like this. Watching Andrew fumble through explanations about "that wedding planner who seemed familiar" makes Max's jaw clench. He knows exactly who Lina Santos is—the woman Andrew destroyed, the one who haunted the edges of family gatherings with her absence. When Rebecca assigns Max to work directly with Lina on the marketing strategy, he tells himself it's purely professional. But the woman who walks into his office bears little resemblance to the broken bride he glimpsed three years ago. This Lina moves with purpose, her dark eyes sharp and assessing. She's built armor around herself, and Max finds himself curious about what lies beneath. Their first working lunch becomes a careful dance of boundaries and unspoken history. Lina orders her food with military precision, checks her phone constantly, and treats every question like a potential trap. When Max mentions Andrew casually, she goes so still he wonders if she's stopped breathing. "Your brother and I have never met," she says, the lie so smooth it's almost believable. The tension breaks when she laughs at something he says about difficult clients. It's a real laugh, unguarded and musical, and for a moment her carefully constructed walls crack just enough to let him glimpse the woman underneath. Max realizes he's in trouble, but he's not sure he cares. The Brazilian restaurant becomes their neutral ground, though neutrality proves impossible when Lina serves him malagueta peppers hot enough to strip paint, watching his suffering with barely concealed satisfaction as his tongue swells and his speech becomes incomprehensible.

Chapter 3: Forced Partnership, Unexpected Chemistry

The car breaks down on a country road in Virginia, because of course it does. Lina stares at the dead dashboard of her beloved yellow Volvo and feels the universe laughing at her expense. Max, who insisted on coming along to scout the wedding venue, looks remarkably calm for someone stranded in the middle of nowhere with a woman who's been alternately helping and tormenting him for weeks. The tow truck driver, TJ, is a godsend wrapped in coveralls and good humor. He can fix the car, but not until morning. The nearby Surrey Lane Farm inn is booked solid with a couples retreat, leaving them with one absurd option: pretend to be a couple seeking relationship help and join the therapy sessions. James, the retreat leader, welcomes them with open arms and assigns them to a room with one enormous four-poster bed draped in romantic gauze. Lina takes one look at the setup and feels her carefully maintained control start to slip. "We can handle this like adults," she tells Max, but her voice lacks its usual conviction. The pickup truck's cab had forced them together, thigh pressed against thigh, and when she accidentally grabbed his crotch to steady herself, the air between them had ignited. The evening's activities include "bumper ball"—essentially human bowling in inflatable spheres. Lina finds herself laughing until her sides ache as she and Max strategize their way through the competition. For the first time in years, she's not thinking three steps ahead or calculating potential disasters. She's just playing, and it feels dangerously close to happiness. But the bed looms between them like a challenge neither is ready to face.

Chapter 4: Walls Crumbling Under Moonlight

The couples therapy session starts as performance art and becomes something else entirely. James asks them to share three things they wish their partner would do differently, and Max goes first with an intensity that catches Lina completely off guard. "I wish you would open up to me," he says, and the fake relationship suddenly feels very real. His eyes never leave hers as he continues, asking her genuine questions she finds herself wanting to answer. When it's her turn, the words come from a place she usually keeps locked away. She talks about being a Black Latina woman in professional spaces, about the impossible balance between strength and vulnerability, about the paralegal job she lost for crying in a courtroom. Max listens without judgment, and something inside her chest loosens for the first time in years. The other couples fade into background noise. This conversation is happening between just the two of them, raw and honest in a way that terrifies her. When Max says he wants to see the potential in them, Lina's breath catches. She's spent three years building walls, and this man is asking her to tear them down with nothing but his word that he'll catch her when she falls. That night, sharing the ridiculous romantic bed, they cross every line she's drawn. Max touches her like she's precious, like she's chosen rather than settled for. She's hoping for mediocre sex, something easy to dismiss and forget. Instead, he proves to be everything she feared—attentive, skilled, completely focused on her pleasure. When he finally brings her to climax, her cries of release shatter more than just the night's silence. In the aftermath, they lie tangled together, both knowing they've crossed a line they can never uncross.

Chapter 5: When Brothers and Broken Promises Collide

They're kissing in the bridal shop's dressing room when Andrew appears like a bad omen made flesh. Lina's first instinct is to run, but there's nowhere to go among the racks of white silk and tulle. The three of them stand in a triangle of tension, surrounded by wedding dresses and the ghosts of broken promises that have haunted them all. Andrew's face cycles through confusion, recognition, and something uglier. "My brother and the woman I was going to marry," he says, and the words land like physical blows. Max steps protectively closer to Lina, but Andrew isn't finished. He's been carrying his own wounds, and now he's ready to share the pain with surgical precision. The revelation comes like a knife twist: Andrew admits he lied about Max's role in their broken engagement. The text message that blamed Max for encouraging the cancellation was fabricated, a coward's way of avoiding full responsibility. Max goes white with shock and rage, while Lina feels the last pieces of her old life crumbling around her feet like broken glass. But Andrew saves his cruelest cut for last. He reminds them both that Lina tried to reconcile after the wedding disaster, that she wanted him even after he humiliated her in front of two hundred guests. The words hang in the air like poison, and Lina watches Max's face close off as doubt creeps in like fog. "You were going to marry him," Max says later, when they're alone. "Even after he didn't show up, you tried to change his mind." The accusation in his voice breaks something inside her chest that she thought had already been destroyed beyond repair.

Chapter 6: Professional Distance, Personal Devastation

Max pulls away like a man waking from a fever dream. The magic of their weekend dissolves under the harsh light of family history and complicated truths. He talks about second choices and shadows, about not wanting to live in Andrew's wake forever. Lina listens to him rationalize their ending and feels her heart turn to stone, the familiar weight of abandonment settling over her shoulders like an old coat. "We both deserve a relationship that doesn't exist in my brother's shadow," he says, and she wants to scream that Andrew's shadow only exists because Max keeps looking for it. But she's learned not to beg, not to chase men who've already decided she's not worth the fight. The lesson cost her three years of therapy and countless sleepless nights, but it stuck. They agree to finish the presentation professionally, communicating through emails that grow shorter and more formal with each exchange. Lina throws herself into work, channeling her pain into perfection. The wedding-concierge concept they develop is brilliant, playing to her strengths while complementing the hotel's existing services. Every detail is flawless because she has nothing left to lose and everything to prove. The morning of the pitch, she walks into the Cartwright conference room like a woman with nothing left to lose. Her presentation is flawless, hitting every note with precision and passion. Rebecca Cartwright smiles and asks thoughtful questions, and Lina knows she's nailed it. When the call comes offering her the position, she's alone in her office, surrounded by the remnants of her old life. The victory tastes bittersweet without Max to share it, but she's learned to celebrate her own successes. She's survived Andrew's abandonment and Max's retreat. She'll survive this too.

Chapter 7: Success Tastes Bitter When Celebrated Alone

Natalia's wedding day dawns perfect and bright, the kind of spring morning that makes promises feel possible again. Lina stands before the assembled guests, her cousin radiant in a jumpsuit that defies every bridal tradition, and prepares to give a toast about love. The irony isn't lost on her—the woman who's sworn off romance speaking about matters of the heart to a crowd of believers. The words come from her heart, shaped by recent pain into something true and hard-won. She talks about vulnerability and courage, about finding someone worth dropping your guard for. As she speaks, she sees Max slip into the reception, devastating in a blue suit that makes her pulse stutter despite everything that's passed between them. "Love doesn't operate in the abstract," she tells the crowd, but her eyes are on Max. "It's between people. The moment you let your guard down with someone and let them into your life—truly into your life—you are at your most vulnerable, but you're also utterly open to a beautiful experience if they reciprocate." The words feel like a confession and a challenge rolled into one. The reception swirls around them with music and laughter, but Lina feels suspended in amber, watching Max navigate the crowd with the careful movements of a man who's made a decision. When he approaches her table, she braces for another goodbye, another explanation about why they can't work. Instead, he asks her to dance, and against her better judgment, she says yes. On the dance floor, surrounded by other couples lost in their own worlds, they move together like they never stopped fitting perfectly.

Chapter 8: Love Finds a Way to Rewrite the Story

Later, on the rooftop garden under a canopy of stars, Max finds her. He looks like a man who's been wrestling with demons and finally won, his usual confidence tempered with something that might be humility. "I've been a pigheaded fool," he says, and the simple honesty of it breaks through her remaining defenses like sunlight through storm clouds. He talks about first choices and right choices, about scaling walls and handling vulnerable hearts with care. When he says he loves her, Lina feels the last of her armor fall away. She's spent so long protecting herself that she almost forgot what it felt like to be truly seen and chosen, not as a consolation prize or a second option, but as someone worth fighting for. "You're not my second choice," she tells him, stepping into his arms. "You're my only choice." The kiss they share tastes like new beginnings and hard-won trust, like all the words they've been too afraid to say finally finding their way home. The city lights twinkle around them, and wedding guests dance below, but their world has narrowed to this moment, this choice, this leap of faith. Their story isn't neat or simple. There will be awkward family dinners and questions about timing, whispers about brothers and broken engagements. But they've learned that love isn't about perfect circumstances—it's about finding someone brave enough to see you completely and choose you anyway. As Max pulls her closer, Lina realizes that sometimes the worst beginning leads to the most beautiful conclusion, and sometimes the heart knows what it wants even when the mind can't make sense of it.

Summary

The rooftop garden becomes their sanctuary, a place where past wounds transform into future possibilities. Max's confession unlocks something in Lina that she thought Andrew had destroyed forever—the ability to believe in love that doesn't require her to diminish herself or apologize for taking up space. They've both learned that vulnerability isn't weakness but the only way to find your way home to someone who matters. As wedding guests dance below and the city lights create their own constellation, Lina and Max write a new ending to an old story. Sometimes the person who disrupts your carefully planned life is exactly the person you need. In a world that often punishes women for feeling too much and men for not feeling enough, they've found a space where they can simply be themselves—complicated, flawed, and perfectly matched in their imperfections. Their love story began with a wedding that never happened, but it ends with the promise of something more enduring than any ceremony could provide.

About Author

Loading

Mia Sosa

Sosa explores multicultural themes and vibrant romantic narratives, creating stories where diverse characters find love through laughter and missteps. Her purpose is to craft contemporary romances that not only entertain but also celebrate the multicultural richness of her characters' worlds. This approach is evident in her work, including her acclaimed novel, "The Worst Best Man", which Entertainment Weekly hailed as "rom-com perfection." Through her humorous and steamy narratives, she deliberately infuses each book with cultural representation, thereby engaging readers who appreciate diverse perspectives.\n\nTransitioning from a decade-long career in First Amendment and media law, Sosa draws on her background to weave complex characters who navigate the challenges of love and identity. Her writing style, characterized by witty dialogue and playful plots, invites readers to explore the imperfections and idiosyncrasies of her characters, making them relatable and endearing. Meanwhile, her stories resonate with those seeking fun, flirty, and sassy narratives, as highlighted by Booklist, which described her as a go-to author in this genre.\n\nReaders benefit from Sosa’s novels by encountering rich and varied cultural tapestries that broaden their understanding of romance in different contexts. Her work is praised by major publications such as The Washington Post and NPR, validating her ability to connect with a wide audience through engaging storytelling. This short bio highlights how Sosa's literary contributions extend beyond mere entertainment, offering a deeper exploration of multiculturalism and love that enriches the reader’s experience.

Read more