Winter in Paradise

Winter in Paradise Plot Summary

Introduction

New Year's Day should have been ordinary for Irene Steele. Instead, a phone call from her husband's secretary shattered her world: Russell was dead in a helicopter crash in the Virgin Islands. But Russell wasn't supposed to be in paradise—he was supposed to be working. As Irene flies south to collect his remains, she discovers her thirty-five-year marriage was built on lies. The man she thought she knew owned a million-dollar villa, kept a Caribbean mistress, and fathered a secret daughter. What begins as a widow's journey to retrieve her husband's ashes becomes an explosive collision of two families who never knew the other existed. In the turquoise waters where Russell died alongside his island lover Rosie Small, devastating truths surface like wreckage from the deep. Love triangles, financial crimes, and buried secrets converge in a tropical setting where nothing is as pristine as it appears.

Chapter 1: The Call That Changed Everything

The phone rang as Irene Steele returned from New Year's dinner with her best friend Lydia. She'd spent the evening discussing their mundane middle-aged complaints—invisible women past fifty, husbands who traveled too much for work. Her Victorian house in Iowa City felt oppressively quiet after Russell's latest business trip to Florida. "Mrs. Steele, this is Marilyn Monroe, Todd Croft's secretary." The woman's voice carried bad news like a loaded gun. "There was an accident. I'm afraid your husband is dead." The words struck Irene like physical blows. Russell dead? In a helicopter crash between Virgin Gorda and somewhere called Anegada? She gripped the phone, her legs suddenly unsteady. Russell was supposed to be handling clients in Tampa or Sarasota, not flying helicopters over Caribbean islands she'd never heard of. "A local woman was also killed," Marilyn continued with clinical detachment. "Mr. Croft has arranged for cremation. Time was of the essence." Irene's mind reeled. Todd Croft, Russell's shadowy boss whom she'd met exactly once thirteen years ago, had authorized cremating her husband's body without her consent. The man who'd controlled their lives from afar was now controlling Russell's death. But the detail that haunted her most was the local woman. What local woman? What was Russell doing with her at seven in the morning on New Year's Day? As Marilyn rattled off coordinates and funeral home details, Irene felt her carefully constructed world crumbling. The money, the renovated Victorian, Russell's supposed corn syrup salesman past—all of it suddenly felt like elaborate theater. She was booking flights to St. Thomas before she hung up, driven by questions that demanded answers only the Caribbean could provide.

Chapter 2: A Hidden Villa in the Caribbean

St. John revealed itself like a fever dream of impossible beauty and shocking deception. Paulette Vickers, the property manager, led them through gates marked "Private" up a winding road to a villa that defied everything Irene thought she knew about her husband. Fifteen million dollars of tropical paradise perched above turquoise waters, complete with infinity pools, private beach access, and nine bedrooms. Irene's sons Baker and Cash flanked her like bodyguards, equally stunned by their father's secret kingdom. Baker, the stay-at-home dad from Houston, kept checking his phone for messages from his surgeon wife Anna. Cash, the failed outdoor store owner from Denver, seemed to shrink into himself as the magnitude of Russell's deception became clear. "Your father was a very private person," Paulette explained, leading them through rooms that felt staged and sterile. Someone had scrubbed away all traces of Russell's life here. The wine cellar held cases of Irene's favorite California chardonnays. The kitchen was stocked with gourmet foods Russell never ate at home. Most unsettling was what they found behind a locked door at the end of the upstairs hallway. The bedroom was decorated like a teenage girl's paradise, with tie-dyed wallpaper and turquoise accents. Letters painted across one wall spelled out a name: MAIA. Russell hadn't just kept a mistress in paradise—he'd been playing father to someone else's child. As Irene stood in that room surrounded by evidence of her husband's double life, she realized the man she'd been married to for thirty-five years was a complete stranger. The ashes arrived that night, delivered to their door like takeout food in an unmarked cardboard box. Douglas Vickers, Paulette's husband, handed over what remained of Russell Steele with the casual efficiency of a UPS driver, leaving the family to confront the brutal finality of cremated dreams.

Chapter 3: Unraveling the Invisible Man

The island's gossip network led Irene to Captain Huck Powers, a grizzled fisherman who'd raised Russell's mistress Rosie Small as his stepdaughter. Meeting him felt like approaching enemy territory, but grief makes strange allies. Huck agreed to take Irene fishing, perhaps recognizing a fellow survivor of Russell's wreckage. On the crystalline waters where Russell had died, Irene found unexpected redemption. Her childhood fishing skills returned as if summoned by desperation, and she pulled in mahi after mahi under Huck's approving gaze. For precious hours, she forgot about betrayal and lies, lost in the ancient rhythm of casting and reeling. The sun burned her pale Iowa skin, the sea salt stung her eyes, but she felt more alive than she had in years. Huck proved to be a reluctant confessor, parceling out details about Rosie with the caution of a man protecting secrets. Rosie had been beautiful, beloved by the island community, and fiercely private about her relationship with the man everyone called the Invisible Man. She'd worked at La Tapa, the island's finest restaurant, serving tourists who returned year after year requesting her specifically. But it was the child, Maia, who haunted their conversation. Twelve years old, biracial, supposedly fathered by some mysterious "Pirate" who'd sailed into Rosie's life during a long-ago Valentine's weekend. As Huck described the girl's intelligence and beauty, Irene felt the final piece of Russell's puzzle clicking into place with devastating clarity.

Chapter 4: When Two Worlds Collide

The confrontation Irene dreaded came when she showed Huck photos of Russell without his sunglasses. Even the weathered sea captain couldn't deny what stared back from the screen. Maia had Russell's half-moon eyebrows, his distinctive nose, his identical smile. She was Russell Steele's daughter, born during his supposed business trip to Florida thirteen years earlier. The Valentine's weekend story was a lie. The Pirate was Russell himself, seducing a young cocktail waitress at Caneel Bay Resort during the same trip that had supposedly launched his lucrative new career. He'd been living a double life from the very beginning, playing devoted husband in Iowa while building a second family in paradise. Huck's reluctant agreement to arrange a meeting between the families felt like negotiating a ceasefire in an undeclared war. Irene's world was about to collide with Rosie's, mediated by a twelve-year-old girl who embodied their shared betrayal. The island setting should have made everything beautiful, but some truths are too ugly for even paradise to hide. Meanwhile, Baker was pursuing his own dangerous liaison with Ayers Wilson, Rosie's best friend and a server at La Tapa. Neither woman knew the men courting them were connected to their shared tragedy. The island's small size made such intersections inevitable, like tropical storms brewing just offshore. As arrangements were made for the families to meet, Irene realized she wasn't just collecting her husband's ashes. She was inheriting his mess, his lies, and somehow, impossibly, his other daughter—the child she'd always wanted but never had.

Chapter 5: The Daughter He Never Mentioned

Maia Small arrived at the villa like a ghost made flesh, Russell's features eerily reflected in her young face. At twelve, she possessed a poise that made the adults seem clumsy by comparison. She knew about Russell's Iowa family, had known for months that her absent father maintained another life somewhere in America's heartland. The meeting unfolded with the surreal politeness of strangers sharing tea over a mass grave. Irene found herself offering drinks and snacks while studying the child who embodied her husband's ultimate betrayal. Maia moved through Russell's villa with familiarity, casually mentioning her bedroom upstairs, the SpaghettiOs in the kitchen cabinet, plans for Anegada trips that would never happen now. Baker and Cash struggled to process having a half-sister, their father's secret daughter who'd enjoyed privileges they'd never known existed. The villa's luxury mocked their childhood memories of financial stress, coupon-clipping, and delayed gratification. Russell had been living like a king in paradise while playing the struggling salesman back home. But it was Ayers Wilson's presence that ignited the afternoon's most explosive revelation. She'd been dating Baker without knowing his connection to the helicopter crash that killed her best friend. When the truth emerged, her fury was magnificent and absolute. The tourist she'd been falling for was the son of the man she blamed for Rosie's death. The emotional wreckage left everyone bloodied. Ayers fled back to her ex-boyfriend, Baker retreated into guilt and longing, Cash drowned his disappointment in rum. Only Maia seemed to navigate the chaos with grace, perhaps because she'd grown up in the eye of Russell's deceptive storm.

Chapter 6: Scattered Ashes, Lingering Questions

The family gathered on Russell's private beach to scatter his remains into the same waters that had claimed his life. The ceremony felt hollow, performed by strangers who'd shared a man without truly knowing him. Irene kept a handful of ashes for Russell's ninety-seven-year-old mother Milly, the only family member who still believed Russell Steele had been an honest man. Maia surprised everyone by producing homemade bath bombs—her entrepreneurial venture with school friend Joanie. One rose-scented sphere for her mother, one pineapple-mint for Russell. As the organic bombs dissolved in the turquoise water, they released fragrances and emotions too complex to parse. The ritual felt like an ending, but endings in paradise come with hidden costs. Baker was flying back to Houston to salvage his marriage to Anna, the cardiothoracic surgeon who'd just confessed her love for a female colleague. Cash planned to return to Colorado with nothing but his golden retriever Winnie and the wreckage of his failed business ventures. Irene would return to Iowa City to bury both Russell and his mother, who was dying in a retirement home, mercifully unaware of her son's crimes. But St. John had claimed them all in different ways. The island's beauty was seductive and dangerous, a tropical Venus flytrap that made deception look like paradise. Russell had built his second life in a place where rules seemed optional and consequences felt as distant as winter snow. As they prepared to scatter across the mainland like Russell's ashes across the Caribbean, none of them could predict how deeply the island's secrets had already infected their blood. Some discoveries change everything—and some changes can never be undone.

Chapter 7: Shadows of Foul Play

Agent Colette Vasco's phone call shattered what little peace Huck had found after the memorial service. The FBI agent's voice was clinical but urgent: the helicopter crash investigation had been transferred from British authorities to American jurisdiction. What everyone assumed was a weather-related tragedy now looked like murder. The revelation hit Huck like a rogue wave. Rosie and Russell hadn't died in an accident caused by January's thunderstorms. Someone had wanted them dead, had planned their deaths with the precision of a military operation. The helicopter crash was an execution disguised as an act of God. Huck thought about Russell's mysterious business dealings, the shell companies and offshore accounts that funded paradise lifestyles. He thought about Todd Croft, the shadow boss who'd arranged for cremation before questions could be asked. The Invisible Man had been invisible for good reason—he'd been hiding from people dangerous enough to kill. Meanwhile, in Iowa City, Irene was sitting vigil as Milly Steele breathed her last. The ninety-seven-year-old woman died believing her son had been an honest corn syrup salesman, never knowing about Caribbean villas or helicopter assassinations. Some mercies arrive disguised as ignorance. Baker was having breakfast with his school wives in Houston when his phone buzzed with the FBI's number. Cash was dropping Maia at Gifft Hill School on St. John, promising to be waiting at three o'clock pickup, when Agent Vasco tried reaching him. Irene was holding Milly's cooling hand when her phone started vibrating with missed calls from San Juan. The investigation was just beginning, but already it was clear that Russell Steele's death had started something that wouldn't end with scattered ashes. The tropical paradise where he'd built his second life was about to become the epicenter of a federal case that would expose secrets darker than anyone imagined.

Summary

In the end, paradise extracted its price from everyone who'd loved Russell Steele. His death in the turquoise waters off Virgin Gorda wasn't the natural disaster it appeared to be, but something far more sinister—a calculated murder that would drag his two families into a federal investigation with international implications. The villa that symbolized his success became evidence in a case that would strip away every remaining illusion about the man they thought they knew. Irene returned to Iowa with more questions than answers, her marriage revealed as thirty-five years of elaborate theater. Her sons faced their own crossroads: Baker's marriage dissolving into his wife's same-sex affair, Cash's business ventures collapsed into bankruptcy. But they'd also found Maia, the sister they'd never known existed, a bright and resilient twelve-year-old who carried Russell's features and perhaps his secrets. The island had taken their father and given them each other, a bittersweet exchange that would bind them together long after the FBI finished excavating Russell's criminal empire. In St. John, where beauty and corruption dance together under eternal sunshine, the Steele family learned that some paradises are built on foundations too dark to survive the light.

About Author

Loading

Elin Hilderbrand

Hilderbrand crafts narratives that delve into the intricate dynamics of family, friendship, and personal transformation, often set against the backdrop of Nantucket Island. Her novels frequently intertwine themes of love, loss, and the revelation of secrets, exploring complex issues such as domestic abuse and health scares. The vivid portrayal of Nantucket in her books enhances the immersive reading experience, while her accessible prose and engaging storytelling make her works popular beach reads.\n\nIn her career, Hilderbrand has not only authored numerous bestsellers, but she has also achieved significant milestones. Her book "Summer of '69" marked a career highlight by debuting at #1 on the "New York Times" bestseller list. Her collaborative work, "The Academy", co-written with her daughter Shelby Cunningham, signifies a personal and professional milestone. Meanwhile, her earlier book, "The Beach Club", was distinguished by People Magazine as “Beach Book of the Week.” Her narrative style, combined with her exploration of relatable themes, continues to resonate with readers seeking both escapism and depth.\n\nThe impact of Hilderbrand's work extends beyond the pages of her books, as she is celebrated for her resilience and openness about her personal battles, such as her experience as a breast cancer survivor. This aspect of her bio underscores her role as a motivational figure, sharing her journey through public speaking engagements. Her novels' adaptations, including "The Perfect Couple" on Netflix, further amplify her influence and connect her storytelling to a broader audience, confirming her position as a beloved figure in contemporary literature.

Read more